California Property Insurance: The Renewal Shock Investors Need to Price

by | Nov 20, 2026

Insurance belongs in the underwriting. Review cost, terms, and renewal risk before you buy, refinance, or set a sale price.

California property owners are treating insurance as a line item that can change a deal.

That is the point of this video. Review the renewal, the policy terms, the deductible, the insured value, and the alternatives before you commit to a purchase, refinance, or sale price. A broker who works with rental property can help compare actual options. The policy controls the coverage.

Insurance expense can reduce NOI. At a 5% capitalization rate, a $1 annual change in stabilized NOI corresponds to a $20 change in value under the simple income-capitalization formula. That is an underwriting illustration, not an appraisal or a prediction of a property’s sale price.

The California FAIR Plan is a last-resort option for basic property coverage when traditional-market coverage is not reasonably available. Its dwelling policy is named-peril coverage, and supplemental policies can be necessary. A licensed broker should review the policy, limits, endorsements, exclusions, DIC, flood, and earthquake needs for the specific property.

For a rental activity, insurance is generally a deductible rental expense to the extent allocated to rental use. Mixed-use properties and loss limitations require a fact-specific tax analysis. Do not treat a deduction as a reason to ignore the cash expense.

Before you act, run the numbers with your broker, tax advisor, lender, and other advisors as appropriate.

Timing and coverage note, reviewed November 19, 2026

This recording discusses conditions and expected changes during 2026. The January 7, 2025 wildfire moratorium was a one-year protection against wildfire-risk cancellation or nonrenewal for residential properties in ZIP codes identified by CDI. It was not a statewide ban and it did not guarantee renewal for every reason. The January 7, 2025 protection has ended.

The video was recorded before October 15, 2026. The FAIR Plan discussion reflects what owners were expecting then. Use your own written renewal quote, not a statewide figure, to estimate your change in cost.

The transcript below remains unchanged so viewers can distinguish the recording from the current clarification.

Educational information only. This is not insurance, tax, legal, valuation, or investment advice.

Full transcript from the supplied SRT

Timed caption-review transcript. The text and timing below are intentionally preserved, including historical predictions and informal language. The caption-review file applies five presentation-only edits to the verified spoken source: host/brand spelling, FAIR Plan capitalization, and “nonadmitted” styling. Do not edit it to conceal the correction note above.

00:00 Okay, we are back, Stephen Morris here with Advise RE, and today we’ve got another topic, California-related, and you guessed it, we’re gonna be talking about insurance. Yeah, what a boring topic, right? And so for a long period of time, insurance was just one of those things that was sort of on the side as an additional cost to running your property. Today, it’s the headline news. People are watching mortgage rates, but they really should be watching insurance in the state of California.

00:26 Here’s why. So there’s a few things going on here with insurance that relate to January 7th. So January 7th, 2025 is when the LA wildfires happened, and insurance carriers could not drop any customers for over a year. They are gonna start dropping their insured, and they already have been. And since 2021, they’ve dropped over 400,000 policies, and they’re continuing to do so at an even faster rate. They’re asking all sorts of interesting questions now that they may not have asked before.

01:00 For example, how old’s your building? Anything over 30 years, they start to get queasy. They’re looking at satellite photos. They’re not interested in flat roofs. They’re not interested in crawl spaces under your property. They’re finding all sorts of ways to disqualify your building, and they’re doing so without much of an explanation. They’re saying, here’s a letter. We’re not interested in renewing you any further. The next date we have to think about is October 15th.

01:23 California’s FAIR Plan is about to go up almost 30%. And you can imagine that those rates are going to substantially increase the cost of ownership in apartment buildings, especially as us real estate investors are looking at that line item that, like I said before, used to be kind of a side thought, now is a major feature of our annual cash flow. The only good news about the FAIR Plan is that the coverage amount moved up to around $3 million, and four units can now qualify as well, whereas previously it was not able to.

01:50 So you might be asking yourself, well, if the premium for my apartment building jumped up, let’s just say $15,000, that sucks, but that’s not the end of the world. There’s not gonna be that much of an impact on value of my property, right? Wrong. The problem is, especially when we’re valuing residential real estate or multifamily, we’re looking at the value as a function of net operating income. And so when we’re looking at valuing a property, we’re taking the net operating income, applying a cap rate, and essentially determining the value based on that.

02:22 Every dollar of expense that the property is incurring has a roughly $20 decrease in value for the year. So if you can imagine, if we’re applying typically, let’s say a 5% capitalization rate, $1 is a $20 reduction in value. And so if we’re talking about $10,000, we’re talking about roughly a $200,000 reduction in value over the value of the property. That is substantial, and when it comes time for you to sell, you’re gonna find your buyers less willing to pay that high cost because, hey, insurance rates have moved up.

02:53 That’s another expense they have to consider. And when costs move up, you’ve got to lower the value in order to chase that same yield. It’s a big problem, and I’m not so sure exactly how they’re gonna solve it without substantial insurance reform in the state of California. So are you hopeless? No, you’re not. There are a few things you can do. Number one is you should be working with a broker who truly understands rentals, looks at the market constantly, has the largest breadth of carriers that they reach out to, and see if there’s some room to negotiate rates.

03:23 Admitted carriers sometimes might be a lot more than nonadmitted carriers. And so they may have options available for you that you may not have considered after your previous insurance broker didn’t have access to. Number two is harden your building. And we’re talking about putting in things that would reduce the chance of fire, make sure that security gating’s in place, make sure the property’s up to code. All these things will greatly improve your chances of having a lower rate, or at the very minimum actually being insured without having to resort to the California FAIR Plan.

03:51 Next, take into consideration tax. So with a multifamily property that’s placed in service for rent, well, fortunately, the insurance costs are deductible. But on your primary residence, it is not. And so you’ve gotta take that cost into consideration accordingly after tax expenses are way more expensive than pre-tax costs. Lastly, it’s time for you to run the numbers. If the insurance costs are dragging down your NOI, it might be time to sell and move into a different performing asset.

04:16 I’m not saying you should immediately jump and panic at selling your property, but it is a strong consideration. And in the absence of any further reform, like I mentioned, or any sort of structural change, or changing climate for that matter in the state of California, I think that high insurance premiums are here to stay for quite some time. Lastly, before insurance was kind of an afterthought, like I mentioned, it was something you just sort of bought and hope to God you never needed it.

04:42 These days, you’ve gotta be actually very actively involved in your insurance. Make sure you’re working with the right brokers to get you the right policies. In this day and age of using AI, it’s never been easier to actually review these policies to understand what exceptions apply and what risks you’re actually covering. Just remember evidence of insurance saying you’ve covered $1 million here on this property, $2 million in aggregate, versus another policy that says the same thing on those evidence of insurance sheets is not enough to tell the tale of what’s actually being covered.

05:11 An important consideration, we actually talk about insurance in our other videos, especially as it relates to construction. And so I highly recommend that you get a lot more involved this year, especially as costs are continuing to rise. And this type of involvement is going to help you out with your assets, and hopefully you’ll have a better performance outcome. Thank you so much for watching and look forward to seeing you in our next video.

05:32 Bye-bye.

Want our real estate advice higher in your Google results?