Hold or Sell? The Tax Impact Every Real Estate Investor Must Know

by Stephen Morris CPA, MBT, CCIM

📌 Should you hold onto your property or sell it for a profit?

The answer lies in taxes. Understanding the tax implications of each decision can make or break your returns as a real estate investor.

✔ How holding affects depreciation & rental income taxes
✔ What selling means for capital gains & tax deductions
✔ Smart tax strategies to maximize profits & minimize liabilities
✔ Market timing & tax laws that impact your decision

💰 Let’s break it down.

Tax Implications of Holding Property

🏡 Keeping a property long-term? Here’s how taxes play a role:

1. Rental Income & Tax Liabilities

✔ Rental income = taxable income
✔ Deductions available for:
➡ Mortgage interest
➡ Property taxes
➡ Insurance
➡ Repairs & maintenance
➡ Property management fees

📌 Example:
💵 You earn $24,000/year in rental income but deduct $10,000 in expenses.
➡ You only pay tax on $14,000 net income at your ordinary tax rate.

💡 Pro Tip:
Classify improvements as repairs to deduct them immediately instead of depreciating over time.

2. Depreciation Deductions

✔ The IRS lets you write off the cost of a rental property over 27.5 years.
✔ This lowers your taxable income every year.

📌 Example:
🏠 You buy a rental property for $275,000.
➡ You can deduct $10,000 per year in depreciation.

💡 Pro Tip:
When you sell, the IRS may recapture depreciation—meaning you pay back some of those tax benefits. 1031 exchanges help defer this tax (more below 👇).

3. Property Appreciation & Tax-Free Growth

✔ Holding property = tax deferral on appreciation
✔ You only pay capital gains tax when you sell
✔ No taxes due if property value rises while you hold it

📌 Example:
🏠 You buy a property for $200K, and it appreciates to $350K.
➡ No taxes due until you sell.

💡 Pro Tip:
Longer holds = lower tax rates on gains. Short-term sales (<1 year) get hit with higher tax rates.

Tax Implications of Selling Property

📌 Selling means paying taxes on your profits. Here’s what you need to know:

1. Capital Gains Tax on Real Estate

✔ Short-Term Capital Gains (Held < 1 Year) = Ordinary Income Tax Rates
✔ Long-Term Capital Gains (Held > 1 Year) = 0%, 15%, or 20% Tax Rate

📌 Example:
🏠 You buy for $250K and sell for $350K.
➡ Profit = $100K
✔ If held <1 year → Taxed as ordinary income (up to 37%)
✔ If held >1 year → Taxed at long-term rates (0-20%)

💡 Pro Tip:
Always hold for at least a year to avoid short-term tax penalties.

2. Depreciation Recapture Tax

✔ If you claimed depreciation deductions, the IRS recaptures some when you sell.
✔ Recaptured depreciation taxed at 25% rate.

📌 Example:
🏠 You deducted $50K in depreciation over the years.
➡ When selling, the IRS taxes that $50K at 25% = $12.5K tax bill.

💡 Pro Tip:
Use a 1031 exchange to defer depreciation recapture when reinvesting in another property.

3. Exemptions & Deductions for Sellers

✔ Primary Residence Exemption (Section 121)
➡ $250K capital gains tax-free if single
➡ $500K tax-free if married
✔ 1031 Exchanges for tax-deferred reinvestments
✔ Closing costs, agent fees, & improvements reduce taxable profit

📌 Example:
🏠 You sell your personal home for $600K (bought for $300K).
➡ Profit = $300K
✔ If married → $500K exclusion → No capital gains tax owed!

💡 Pro Tip:
You must live in the home for 2 out of 5 years before selling to qualify for the tax exemption.

Tax Strategies: Should You Hold or Sell?

✔ When to HOLD:
➡ You want long-term appreciation
➡ Rental cash flow is strong
➡ You’re using depreciation to lower taxes
➡ Selling would trigger high capital gains taxes

✔ When to SELL:
➡ Market prices are high & peaking
➡ You need to free up cash
➡ Tax-free sale (Primary residence exemption)
➡ You plan to reinvest via a 1031 exchange

💡 Pro Tip:
Always time your sale when your income is lower (e.g., retirement) to reduce tax impact.

Advanced Tax Strategies for Holding & Selling

🔹 1. Use a 1031 Exchange (Tax-Deferred Sale)
✔ Sell investment property & reinvest profits into another property
✔ Defers capital gains tax & depreciation recapture
✔ Can be repeated indefinitely

📌 Example:
🏠 You sell a rental for $500K (bought for $250K)
➡ Normally owe $50K+ in capital gains tax
✔ Use a 1031 exchange → Buy a new property → Pay $0 tax

💡 Pro Tip:
1031 exchanges work for investment properties—not primary residences!

🔹 2. Convert Rental Property Into Primary Residence
✔ Live in rental for 2 years before selling
✔ Qualify for $250K-$500K tax-free home sale exemption

📌 Example:
🏠 You own a rental for 10 years → Then live in it for 2 years
✔ Now sell it as a primary residence → Up to $500K tax-free gains

💡 Pro Tip:
IRS limits how much of your gain can be excluded based on how long it was a rental.

🔹 3. Maximize Depreciation With Cost Segregation
✔ Identify faster-depreciating assets (appliances, flooring, fixtures)
✔ Boost upfront tax deductions
✔ Lower taxable rental income

📌 Example:
A $300K rental property normally depreciates over 27.5 years.
➡ Cost segregation study allows $50K in deductions upfront instead of over decades!

💡 Pro Tip:
Best for high-income investors who want to lower taxable income.

Final Verdict: Should You Hold or Sell Your Property?

✔ Hold Property If:
✅ You want long-term wealth growth
✅ You’re using depreciation to reduce taxes
✅ You plan to pass property to heirs (step-up basis = $0 taxes)
✅ You avoid capital gains tax via a 1031 exchange

✔ Sell Property If:
✅ You qualify for primary residence tax exemption
✅ You want to cash out at market peak
✅ You need liquidity for new investments
✅ You’re facing high maintenance or holding costs

 

 

Back to Advise RE Resource Center articles list